SlashFan's Review Thread

Come here to get your song preffesionally reviewed.


How I review songs:



Sync: x/50

Song Choice: (How "Fun" it is to play in FoFiX) x/50

Note Placement: x/50

How Fun It Is to Play x/50






EXAMPLE REVIEWS



EXAMPLE REVIEWS:

[size=150]Blood Brothers-Iron Maiden[/size]
Fretted by lukarocker
In the pack "Maiden Hero"

[size=150]Sync-48/50[/size]
Song was greatly sync to the music. Some parts I felt could have used a variable BPM, but other than that it is overall synced very well.
[size=150]Note Placement-32/50[/size]
During the 1st verse, I noticed that you fretted the BASS line in the GUITAR part. There was no guitar during that part, so you should have let that stay blank. The guitar solo I felt was fretted very carefully, but some parts I think you overdid a TINY little bit. The note placement for the solo though seemed to be planned and was overall very good fretted. Another BASS part I saw was fretted again after the bridge following a solo. The placement was good, but should have been left blank as it was the GUITAR part. Some notes are marked as sustains in the song, that I felt should have been left as single notes also. There was also some ascend/desend issues in some of the bridges throughout the song too. The second guitar solo had very minimal issues as far as note placement which was a great thing (still though, there were some unnessecary sustains) and I thought I would add that in. Some parts of this solo more so at the end there was 2-3 notes out of sync by about a quarter of a second if not a little less. And also the last bridge before the end you placed low notes as high notes.
[size=150]How Fun to Play-46/50[/size]
Overall the song was very fun to play and I throughly enjoyed it.
[size=150]Song Choice-45/50[/size]
Song was great if your a Maiden fan. If your not a Maiden fan, or not a fan of slower metal, then this song is DEFINATELEY not for you.
[size=150]Closing Comments[/size]
I enjoyed reviewing your song lukarocker, and throughly enjoyed playing it. I look forward to seeing more of your work around the forums.

[size=150]STATISTICS[/size]
171/200

[size=150]Surfing With the Alien (Live) - Joe Satriani[/size]
Fretted by SUSAltd

[size=150]Sync-50/50[/size]
Hot damn dude. You are amazing. No further comments needed.
[size=150]Note Placement-48/50[/size]
During the second solo around the middle there was a few places I thought should be fretted as taps instead of trills.
[size=150]How Fun to Play-50/50[/size]
Holy cow! Not a song for a beginner, I can say that much. Insanely fun.
[size=150]Song Choice-47/50[/size]
I highly reccomend Joe Satriani songs that are fretted by SUSAltd for anyone looking for a challenge.
[size=150]Closing Comments[/size]
Eh, what can I say. Your just amazing dude. Seriously. Keep fretting like this and you'll be better than Puppetz. Your in the big leagues now dude.

[size=150]STATISTICS[/size]
195/200

*Pokes my song thread*

Sure I will do a few when I find time.

wheee

lol.

meow

FAIL.

WIN

Lol. Anyways, when I get a chance I will get to them.

YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

No prob man.

still no review............

cause I have been fretting a lot this weekend dude. sorry its take so long.